EDITIONEN·FR·ქართ

Accréditation Sans Frontières

International Accreditation of Healthcare Facilities

LatestASF Approves Confidentiality and Data Protection Policy
All NewsPatient SafetyHospital QualityAmbulatory CareAccreditationQuality ImprovementWHO & UNASF StandardsASF News
Prof. Giorgi Pkhakadze, MD, MPH, PhD

Prof. Giorgi Pkhakadze, MD, MPH, PhD

Professor, David Tvildiani Medical University  |  Chair, Public Health Institute of Georgia  |  Founder & President, Accréditation Sans Frontières (ASF)

ORCID: 0000-0001-7609-4515

November 2024 · Governance · 7 min read · ~1,700 words

Prof. Giorgi Pkhakadze, MD, MPH, PhD — Professor, David Tvildiani Medical University | Chair, Public Health Institute of Georgia | Founder, Accréditation Sans Frontières | ORCID: 0000-0001-7609-4515

ASF has formally approved its Confidentiality and Data Protection Policy (ASF-GOV-004), establishing the legal and ethical framework governing how information is collected, held, disclosed, and protected across all accreditation activities.

Why Accreditation Bodies Require a Formal Confidentiality Framework

Healthcare accreditation is built on trust. When a facility submits to an external evaluation, it shares sensitive operational data — clinical protocols, staffing configurations, incident logs, management system documentation, and sometimes patient-related process records. The accreditation body that receives this information occupies a position of significant responsibility: it must protect what it is given, use it only for the purpose for which it was shared, and define clearly what can and cannot be disclosed to third parties.

This is not a matter of administrative preference. It is a legal obligation under data protection law, an ethical requirement under internationally recognised governance standards, and increasingly a formal criterion in accreditation body evaluations. The European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), Regulation (EU) 2016/679, establishes that personal data — and health data specifically — must be processed under defined lawful bases, with proportionality, purpose limitation, and data minimisation as binding principles [1]. In France, where ASF is legally domiciled, these obligations are reinforced by the Loi Informatique et Libertés (Law No. 78-17), which applies data protection requirements across all data processing activities conducted by entities established under French law [2].

An accreditation body that lacks a formal, published confidentiality policy operates without a defined framework for one of its most sensitive governance functions. It creates exposure for itself and uncertainty for the facilities it evaluates. ASF-GOV-004 addresses this directly.

What ASF-GOV-004 Establishes

ASF-GOV-004 defines four operational domains of confidentiality management:

1. Classification of confidential information. The policy distinguishes between information that is inherently confidential — facility-specific findings, surveyor assessments, internal compliance documentation, non-conformity records — and information that is appropriately public, such as the accreditation status of a facility listed in the ASF Public Registry. This distinction is fundamental: it allows ASF to maintain a transparent, verifiable public registry while ensuring that the operational detail behind each accreditation decision remains protected.

2. Registry and public disclosure rules. The ASF Public Registry discloses accreditation status, the category of standards applied, and the validity period of a certificate. It does not disclose the content of survey findings, the number or category of non-conformities identified, or the detailed scoring of individual standards. This model aligns with the practice of major international accreditation bodies and with ISQua EEA governance requirements for transparency without exposing proprietary operational data [3].

3. Third-party disclosure rules. ASF-GOV-004 sets explicit rules on when information may be shared with entities other than the accredited facility. Disclosure to regulatory authorities is permitted only where legally mandated. Disclosure to commercial third parties is prohibited without explicit written consent from the facility. Research use of aggregate, anonymised data is permitted under defined conditions aligned with GDPR Article 89, which governs processing for research and statistical purposes [1].

4. Post-engagement obligations. When an accreditation relationship ends — whether through expiry, withdrawal, or non-renewal — ASF-GOV-004 defines the retention and destruction schedule for facility-specific data. Retention periods are set to satisfy legal audit requirements while preventing indefinite storage of sensitive operational records. This aligns with the GDPR storage limitation principle, which requires that personal and organisational data be held no longer than necessary for the stated purpose [1].

Health Data as a Special Category: Why Stricter Rules Apply

The accreditation process necessarily involves health-related organisational data — documentation of clinical processes, infection control protocols, medication management systems, and patient safety incident records. GDPR Article 9 designates health data as a special category of personal data, subject to heightened protection requirements and a narrower set of lawful processing bases [1]. While most accreditation documentation is organisational rather than individual in character, the boundary between organisational health system data and personal health data is not always clear — particularly in small facilities where individual case examples may appear in process documentation.

ASF-GOV-004 addresses this by requiring that surveyors and ASF staff handle all facility documentation as if it may contain personal health data, applying the heightened protection standard as a default. This is consistent with the principle of privacy by design and by default established in GDPR Article 25, which requires that data controllers implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to ensure that, by default, only necessary data is processed [1].

Surveyor Obligations Under the Policy

Surveyors are the operational interface between ASF and accredited facilities. They access the most detailed facility information — physical areas, management systems, patient care processes — and their observations form the basis of accreditation decisions. ASF-GOV-004 imposes specific obligations on surveyors: a binding confidentiality undertaking signed prior to any survey engagement, prohibition on sharing facility-specific findings outside the formal reporting structure, and a post-engagement restriction on discussing survey content in professional or public contexts without ASF authorisation.

These requirements are aligned with the approach taken by other ISQua EEA-recognised accreditation bodies, which uniformly treat surveyor confidentiality obligations as a core governance requirement [3]. The 5th Edition of ISQua’s Guidelines and Principles for the Development of Health and Social Care Standards includes governance of surveyor conduct and information handling as a standard-setting criterion [3]. ASF-GOV-004 ensures that ASF’s governance framework meets this criterion explicitly.

Transparency as a Governance Principle

Confidentiality and transparency are not in opposition — they operate at different levels of disclosure. Confidentiality governs operational detail; transparency governs the existence and status of accreditation. ASF’s approach makes the accreditation status of every certified facility publicly verifiable through the ASF Registry, while protecting the specific findings and documentation behind that status. This distinction is fundamental to the credibility of accreditation as a quality signal: a certificate that reflects a verifiable, independent evaluation process is meaningful precisely because the evaluation itself was rigorous and its content protected from commercial pressure or public misuse.

The policy is published in full at france-asf.fr/about/transparency/confidentiality-policy/.


Key Questions: Confidentiality and Data Protection in Accreditation

Q1. What information does ASF keep confidential from third parties?
Survey findings, non-conformity records, surveyor assessments, and all facility-specific documentation submitted as part of the accreditation process are confidential. ASF does not share this information with other healthcare facilities, commercial entities, media, or any third party without the explicit written consent of the accredited facility, except where legally mandated by regulatory authority.

Q2. What information is publicly available about an accredited facility?
The ASF Public Registry discloses the facility name, the accreditation standard applied, the accreditation status (accredited, suspended, or expired), and the certificate validity dates. This level of disclosure allows patients, regulators, and partners to verify accreditation status without accessing confidential evaluation detail.

Q3. How does GDPR apply to an accreditation body like ASF?
ASF is legally established in France and processes data as part of its accreditation activities, making it a data controller subject to GDPR. The regulation requires ASF to process data under a defined lawful basis, limit data use to the stated purpose, retain data only as long as necessary, and implement appropriate security measures. ASF-GOV-004 operationalises these requirements across the accreditation cycle.

Q4. What happens to facility data after an accreditation relationship ends?
ASF-GOV-004 sets defined retention periods aligned with legal audit requirements. After the retention period expires, facility-specific documentation is securely destroyed. Data is not retained indefinitely, and no commercial use of retained data is permitted.

Q5. How does ASF’s confidentiality framework affect facilities considering accreditation?
Facilities can submit to ASF’s evaluation process with the assurance that their operational documentation, non-conformity records, and clinical system information will not be disclosed to competitors, the media, or commercial third parties. The existence of a formal, published, legally-grounded confidentiality policy is itself a governance signal — it indicates that ASF treats its information management obligations as a formal institutional responsibility, not an informal commitment.


Recommendations for Healthcare Facilities on Accreditation Confidentiality

  1. Ask every accreditation body for its published confidentiality policy before submitting documentation. A credible accreditation body should be able to produce a formal, documented confidentiality policy that specifies what will be held, how it will be protected, and when it will be destroyed. Absence of such a document is a governance gap that should inform the selection decision.
  2. Verify that the accreditor’s data processing complies with applicable data protection law in your jurisdiction. GDPR applies to any accreditation body processing data about EU-based facilities. Outside the EU, equivalent national frameworks apply. Facilities should confirm that their accreditor operates under a legally compliant data protection framework — not merely an internal best-efforts commitment.
  3. Confirm the distinction between public registry disclosure and operational confidentiality. Before submitting sensitive documentation, facilities should understand precisely what will appear in the accreditor’s public registry and what will remain protected. This distinction defines the public signal the facility consents to and the operational detail it retains control over.
  4. Include accreditor confidentiality obligations in your own data protection impact assessment. GDPR Article 35 requires data protection impact assessments for high-risk processing activities. Engaging with an external accreditation body constitutes a data processing activity; the accreditor’s data governance framework should be evaluated as part of the facility’s own DPIA process.
  5. Review post-engagement data retention terms before signing an accreditation agreement. The end of an accreditation relationship does not automatically end data retention. Facilities should confirm the retention schedule, the conditions for early destruction, and whether they retain the right to request deletion of their documentation after the accreditation cycle ends.

References

  1. European Parliament and Council. “Regulation (EU) 2016/679 on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data (General Data Protection Regulation).” Official Journal of the European Union, L 119, 4 May 2016. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32016R0679.
  2. République française. “Loi n° 78-17 du 6 janvier 1978 relative à l’informatique, aux fichiers et aux libertés.” Commission Nationale de l’Informatique et des Libertés (CNIL), consolidated text. https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/loda/id/JORFTEXT000000886460.
  3. ISQua External Evaluation Association (ISQua EEA). “Guidelines and Principles for the Development of Health and Social Care Standards, 5th Edition.” Geneva: ISQua EEA, 2021. https://isqua.org/external-evaluation.html.
  4. European Data Protection Board. “Guidelines 05/2020 on consent under Regulation 2016/679.” Version 1.1, adopted 4 May 2020. https://edpb.europa.eu/our-work-tools/our-documents/guidelines/.
  5. International Organization for Standardization. “ISO/IEC 27001:2022 Information security, cybersecurity and privacy protection — Information security management systems.” Geneva: ISO, 2022. https://www.iso.org/standard/82875.html.

About Accréditation Sans Frontières (ASF)
ASF is an international healthcare accreditation standards body legally established in Paris in 2020, with offices in Geneva and Tbilisi. ASF develops evidence-based accreditation standards for hospitals, ambulatory clinics, long-term care facilities, and primary health care settings. The full ASF Confidentiality and Data Protection Policy (ASF-GOV-004) is available at: france-asf.fr/about/transparency/confidentiality-policy/