Standards › ASF Health Standards v10 › Standard 60
Standard 60
Surgical and Specialty Clinics
Surgical and specialty clinics, including operating theatre and surgical safety: surgeons operate within granted privileges, the surgical safety checklist and site marking used for every operation, anaesthesia and sedation given with monitoring and emergency equipment, infection and thrombosis prevented, and patients recovered, discharged and followed up safely..
Each criterion is shown in three settings: Humanitarian settings, Transition and fragile, and Standard. In standard settings, every criterion is Must.
Training colours: red means essential, green recommended, yellow optional. Each course shows its level for each setting: humanitarian, transition and fragile, and standard.
60.1Surgeons Operate Only Within Their Granted PrivilegesHumanitarian settings: MustTransition and fragile: MustStandard: Must
Each surgeon has documented privileges for the procedures they perform. The operating list is checked against those privileges before each session, and no procedure is done outside them.
Why it matters.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Review the operating lists and the privileges register for every session in the last 3 months, including any procedure added at short notice.
1. Each surgeon has documented privileges for the procedures they perform.
Method. Compare each surgeon on the sampled lists with the privileges register.
Evidence to show. Surgeon privileges register (SSC-REG-001).
Pass when. Every sampled surgeon has privileges recorded for the procedure.
2. The operating list is checked against privileges before each session.
Method. Check each sampled list for the privileges check and its date.
Evidence to show. Surgeon privileges and operating list check (SSC-SOP-001).
Pass when. Every sampled list has a privileges check dated before the session.
3. No procedure is done outside privileges, including short-notice additions.
Method. Check each short-notice addition for the privileges check and approval.
Evidence to show. Surgeon privileges and operating list check (SSC-SOP-001).
Pass when. Every short-notice addition has a privileges check and approval recorded.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). A general surgeon performs a vascular procedure added at short notice without privileges, and the patient has a major bleed.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Keeps the Surgeon privileges register (SSC-REG-001); qualification and scope register (SPM-REG-002, existing, reused); staff qualification register | Must |
| Manager (ISCO 1342) | Maintains the Surgeon privileges and operating list check | Must |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SSC-SOP-001 · Surgeon privileges and operating list check | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SSC-REG-001 · Surgeon privileges register | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Credentialing, Competence and the Training Matrix (T-14) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- WHO (2019). Surgical Care at the District Hospital. Used for: Surgeon competence and scope of practice. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/surgical-care-at-the-district-hospital/
60.2The Surgical Safety Checklist and Site Marking Are Used for Every OperationHumanitarian settings: MustTransition and fragile: MustStandard: Must
The surgical safety checklist is completed at sign-in, time-out and sign-out for every operation, and the operation site is marked and confirmed with the patient.
Why it matters.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Observe a sample of operations on several days and audit the checklist records for every operation in the last 3 months.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). An operation proceeds on the wrong side because the site was not marked and the time-out was skipped.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Manager (ISCO 1342) | Checks the criterion at each review | Must |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SRG-SOP-002 · SRG-SOP-002 | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-SOP-001 · Surgical safety checklist procedure | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-POL-001 · Surgical safety checklist and team pause | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Governing body members | N/A | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Patient Identification, Informed Consent and Patient Rights (T-07) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- WHO (2009). Guidelines for Safe Surgery 2009: Safe Surgery Saves Lives. Used for: Surgical safety checklist and site marking. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/guidelines-for-safe-surgery-2009-safe-surgery-saves-lives/
60.3Anaesthesia and Sedation Are Given With Monitoring and Emergency EquipmentHumanitarian settings: MinimumTransition and fragile: MustStandard: Must
Anaesthesia and sedation are given by credentialed clinicians, with continuous monitoring, the emergency equipment checked, and a recovery area ready.
Why it matters.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Review anaesthesia and sedation records and the emergency equipment checks for every procedure with sedation or anaesthesia in the last 6 months.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). A sedated patient desaturates in recovery, and the suction and oxygen are not checked or ready.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Manager (ISCO 1342) | Checks the criterion at each review | Must |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SRG-POL-002 · Anaesthesia safety and monitoring | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Governing body members | N/A | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-FRM-002 · Anaesthesia record and monitoring chart | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-FRM-003 · Anaesthesia machine and equipment check | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| DAY-SOP-002 · Sedation and anaesthesia level, and response to complications | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Safety & Emergency Preparedness (AMB-05) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- WHO (2019). Anaesthesia at the district hospital. Used for: Monitoring, pulse oximetry and equipment. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/anaesthesia-at-the-district-hospital/
60.4Surgical Site Infection and Thrombosis Are PreventedHumanitarian settings: MinimumTransition and fragile: MediumStandard: Must
The surgical site infection bundle and the VTE assessment are applied to each patient, with hand hygiene and sterile technique followed in the operating area.
Why it matters.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Review the infection bundle and VTE records for every operation in the last 6 months, and the hand hygiene audit for the operating area.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). An operation is done without a VTE assessment, and the patient has a pulmonary embolism on day three.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Manager (ISCO 1342) | Checks the criterion at each review | Medium |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SRG-POL-003 · Surgical site infection prevention | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Governing body members | N/A | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-SOP-003 · Surgical site infection prevention bundle | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-FRM-004 · Surgical site infection bundle compliance record | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Hand Hygiene and Standard Precautions (T-06) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- WHO (2018). Global guidelines for the prevention of surgical site infection, second edition. Used for: Surgical site infection prevention. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/global-guidelines-for-the-prevention-of-surgical-site-infection-second-edition/
- NICE (2018). Venous thromboembolism in over 16s: reducing the risk of hospital-acquired deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism. Used for: Reducing hospital-acquired VTE risk. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/venous-thromboembolism-in-over-16s-reducing-the-risk-of-hospital-acquired-deep-vein-thrombosis-or-pulmonary-embolism/
60.5Patients Recover, Are Discharged and Are Followed Up SafelyHumanitarian settings: MinimumTransition and fragile: MediumStandard: Must
Each patient recovers under monitoring until the discharge criteria are met, leaves with an escort and written advice, and is followed up for complications through the set pathway.
Why it matters.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Review discharge and follow-up records for every operation in the last 6 months, including patients who had a complication.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). A patient with a wound complication after a day procedure is discharged with no named contact and presents late with sepsis.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Manager (ISCO 1342) | Checks the criterion at each review | Medium |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DAY-SOP-001 · Recovery monitoring and discharge criteria | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| DAY-FRM-003 · Recovery observation and discharge criteria record | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Aftercare & Follow-up: Closing the Loop After Every Visit (AMB-06) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- Immediate Post-anaesthesia Recovery 2013 (Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland, 2013)
60.6The Surgical Safety Checklist Is UsedHumanitarian settings: MinimumTransition and fragile: MustStandard: Must
WHO’s Surgical Safety Checklist is completed, out loud, as a team pause for every procedure — not filed as paperwork after the fact — and includes explicit verification of correct patient, correct procedure, and correct body site, with the site physically marked before the patient enters theatre.
Why it matters. The surgical safety checklist works only when the team says it out loud, together, at each pause. A checklist filed after the operation protects no one.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Observe 5 procedures on the day of assessment, or from the last month if none are running. For each, check the checklist record for all three pauses. Check the team’s spoken confirmation at the time-out.
1. The checklist is completed aloud at all three pauses.
Method. Observe the pauses for each of the 5 procedures and check the record.
Evidence to show. Surgical safety checklist record (SRG-FRM-001).
Pass when. At least 90% of procedures show all three pauses completed aloud.
2. Identity is checked against the identification log.
Method. Check the patient identification log for each of the 5 procedures.
Evidence to show. Patient identification check log (ID-FRM-001).
Pass when. Every sampled procedure has an identity check recorded.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). A procedure starts with no time-out, or the checklist is completed after the patient has left the theatre.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Nurse (ISCO 2221) | Completes the Surgical safety checklist record | Must |
| Manager (ISCO 1342) | Checks the criterion at each review | Must |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SRG-SOP-001 · Surgical safety checklist procedure | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-FRM-001 · Surgical safety checklist record | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-POL-001 · Surgical safety checklist and team pause | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Governing body members | N/A | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Ophthalmology & Day Surgery Safety (AMB-15) | Manager; Nurse |
| Care & Treatment: Clinical Standards for Accreditation (H-04) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- WHO (2009). Guidelines for Safe Surgery 2009: Safe Surgery Saves Lives. Used for: Checklist use in every operation. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/guidelines-for-safe-surgery-2009-safe-surgery-saves-lives/
60.7Anaesthesia Is Delivered SafelyHumanitarian settings: MinimumTransition and fragile: MustStandard: Must
Anaesthesia follows defined safety protocols with continuous monitoring throughout the procedure, appropriate to the level of anaesthesia and the patient’s specific risk profile.
Why it matters. Anaesthesia is the highest-risk part of the day for many patients. Continuous monitoring through the whole procedure, matched to the level of anaesthesia, is the standard that finds the problem early.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Review 10 anaesthesia records from the last month, and check the machine check records for the last 30 days.
1. Anaesthesia follows a written protocol.
Method. Read the anaesthesia protocol and check its review date.
Evidence to show. Anaesthesia safety and monitoring (SRG-POL-002).
Pass when. The protocol is current and approved by the lead anaesthetist.
2. The patient is monitored continuously from induction to recovery.
Method. Check each of the 10 records for monitoring at the set interval through the case.
Evidence to show. Anaesthesia record and monitoring chart (SRG-FRM-002).
Pass when. At least 90% of records show continuous monitoring.
3. Anaesthetic equipment is checked before each list.
Method. Check the machine check record for each list in the last 30 days.
Evidence to show. Anaesthesia machine and equipment check (SRG-FRM-003).
Pass when. At least 90% of lists have a recorded check before the first case.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). A patient is anaesthetised with no monitoring, or on equipment that has not been checked.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Manager (ISCO 1342) | Maintains the Anaesthesia safety policy | Must |
| Nurse (ISCO 2221) | Completes the Anaesthesia record and monitoring chart | Must |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SRG-FRM-002 · Anaesthesia record and monitoring chart | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-FRM-003 · Anaesthesia machine and equipment check | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-POL-002 · Anaesthesia safety and monitoring | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Governing body members | N/A | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Emergency Medical Equipment & AED Readiness (MED-02) | Manager; Nurse |
| Care & Treatment: Clinical Standards for Accreditation (H-04) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- WHO (2019). Anaesthesia at the district hospital. Used for: Safe delivery of anaesthesia. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/anaesthesia-at-the-district-hospital/
60.8Surgical Site Infection Is Actively PreventedHumanitarian settings: MustTransition and fragile: MustStandard: Must
A defined surgical site infection prevention bundle is followed for every procedure — a specific, checkable set of practices, not general good intentions about cleanliness.
Why it matters. Infections after surgery are preventable with a set of checkable practices. A bundle, followed for every procedure and measured, is what makes prevention real.
How the surveyor verifies this criterion
Sample. Review the compliance record for the last 3 months, the surgical site infection register for the same period, and 10 procedures.
1. Each procedure follows the bundle.
Method. Check the bundle compliance record for each of the 10 procedures.
Evidence to show. Surgical site infection bundle compliance record (SRG-FRM-004).
Pass when. At least 90% of procedures have every part of the bundle recorded as done.
2. Surgical site infections are tracked and reviewed.
Method. Check the surveillance register and the review record for the period.
Evidence to show. Healthcare-associated infection surveillance register (HOS-REG-005).
Pass when. Every infection is recorded and reviewed within 7 days.
Immediate fail (any one means the criterion is not met). A procedure starts without the bundle, or a surgical site infection is found with no review.
Staff responsible
| Role | Responsibility | Level |
|---|---|---|
| Nurse (ISCO 2221) | Completes the Surgical site infection bundle compliance record | Must |
| Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Keeps the Healthcare-associated infection surveillance register | Must |
Documents: who does each step
| Document | Writes | Approves | Fills in | Checks and signs | Files and uploads |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SRG-SOP-003 · Surgical site infection prevention bundle | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-FRM-004 · Surgical site infection bundle compliance record | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) | Manager (ISCO 1342) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
| SRG-POL-003 · Surgical site infection prevention | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Governing body members | N/A | Chief executive (ISCO 1120) | Secretary (ISCO 3344) |
E-learning: who must take each course
| Course | Who must take it |
|---|---|
| Hand Hygiene and Standard Precautions (T-06) | Manager; Nurse |
| Infection Prevention & Control (MT-05) | Manager; Nurse |
References
- WHO (2018). Global guidelines for the prevention of surgical site infection, second edition. Used for: Active SSI prevention. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/global-guidelines-for-the-prevention-of-surgical-site-infection-second-edition/
- WHO (n.d.). Implementation manual to support the prevention of surgical site infections at the facility level: turning recommendations into practice. Used for: Facility-level SSI prevention. https://news.gmj.ge/guideline/implementation-manual-to-support-the-prevention-of-surgical-site-infections-at-the-facility-level-turning-recommendations-into-practice/
Who is responsible for Standard 60
Each criterion names the positions responsible for it. Every position links to its own terms of reference.
Role details: reporting, supervision and training
Training shown is the general recommendation. Role-specific training is set in the next improvement round.
| Role | Reports to | Supervises | Recommended training |
|---|---|---|---|
| Medical director | Chief medical officer (CMO) | Ethics committee secretary, Clinical governance lead | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Infection prevention and control (IPC) lead | Quality manager | IPC nurse | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| IPC nurse | Infection prevention and control (IPC) lead | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Head of department (per specialty) | Medical director | Consultant physician (internal medicine), Resident physician / house officer | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Surgeon (general surgery) | Head of department (per specialty) | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Anaesthesiologist | Head of department (per specialty) | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Registered nurse | Head nurse / ward manager | Nursing associate, Health care assistant / nursing aide | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Operating theatre nurse | Theatre manager | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Anaesthetic nurse | Head of department (per specialty) | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Same-day procedure nurse | Walk-in clinic physician | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Theatre technician / scrub practitioner | Theatre manager | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
| Anaesthesia technician | Head of department (per specialty) | None | Facility induction; safeguarding adults (general recommendation) |
Questions and answers
The criterion text is the authority. These answers summarise it.
Who does Standard 67 apply to?
Surgical and specialty clinics that carry out operations or procedures under anaesthesia or sedation, including the operating theatre and the recovery and discharge of patients.
What do the colours mean for this standard?
Red (Must) is required. Green (Medium) is recommended. Yellow (Minimum) is the lowest acceptable level in humanitarian settings. Standard setting is Must on every criterion.
Which surgeons may operate?
Under 60.1 each surgeon operates only within the procedures and privileges granted to them, and the list is checked and kept current.
Is the surgical safety checklist used?
Yes. Under 60.2 and 60.6 the surgical safety checklist and site marking are used for every operation, with the team confirming each step before incision.
How is anaesthesia given?
Under 60.3 and 60.7 anaesthesia and sedation are given with monitoring, emergency equipment and a trained person present for the whole procedure.
How are infections and clots prevented?
Under 60.4 and 60.8 surgical site infection and venous thromboembolism are prevented through the set measures, and infection is reported and reviewed.
How are patients discharged?
Under 60.5 each patient recovers with monitoring, is discharged with written instructions, and is followed up after the procedure.
Guidelines for this standard
9 guideline(s) are held in the GMJ Guidelines Library and listed here. Each link opens the full guideline on news.gmj.ge. The complete library, grouped by standard, is at Guidelines.
- Immediate Post-anaesthesia Recovery 2013 (AAGBI)
- Guidelines for Safe Surgery 2009: Safe Surgery Saves Lives (World Health Organization)
- Guidelines for Essential Trauma Care (WHO)
- Anaesthesia at the district hospital (World Health Organization)
- Surgical Care at the District Hospital (World Health Organization)
- Implementation manual to support the prevention of surgical site infections at the facility level: turning recommendations into practice (World Health Organization)
- Global guidelines for the prevention of surgical site infection, second edition (World Health Organization)
- Pyomyositis — Clinical guidelines — Diagnosis and treatment manual — MSF Clinical guidelines (Médecins Sans Frontières)
- Dressings — MSF Clinical guidelines (Médecins Sans Frontières)
Also relevant to this standard:
- Guidelines for Day-Case Surgery (Association of Anaesthetists & British Association of Day Surgery)
- Guidelines for medical practitioners who perform cosmetic surgery and procedures (Medical Board of Australia)
- EN 16372:2014 Aesthetic surgery services (European Committee for Standardization)
- Venous thromboembolism in over 16s: reducing the risk of hospital-acquired deep vein thrombosis or pulmonary embolism (National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (UK))
- Best Practice Guidelines on Emergency Surgical Care in Disaster Situations (World Health Organization)
- Necrotising infections of the skin and soft tissues — MSF Clinical guidelines (Médecins Sans Frontières)
- Cutaneous abscess — Clinical guidelines — Diagnosis and treatment manual — MSF Clinical guidelines (Médecins Sans Frontières)
- Aide-mémoire on infection prevention and control measures for Candida auris colonization and infection in patients in health facilities (Pan American Health Organization)